Courage Stretching ‘Round the World: “Hold On”

The events of January, 2026 were the crucible from which formed the Hennepin Avenue United Methodist Church’s Singing Resistance, a Minneapolis-based, grassroots movement using song to protest the illegal federal agent activity in that state and throughout the nation. Time after time in our nation’s history, protest singing has been a tool for organizers, as a form of embodied protest – from “Yankee Doodle,” sung in protest against British imperialism in the 1700’s to “The Battle Hymn of the Republic,” sung by marching suffragists and labor organizers, to songs like โ€œWe Shall Not Be Moved,โ€ and “We Shall Overcome” sung through the years by protestors for civil rights in the early 1900’s and beyond. Every major sea change in American politics and society has come with a soundtrack of people singing together.

However, in the past several decades group singing has waned outside of religious circles. Even in some religious spaces, singing has largely become a competitive reality TV type of thing where “the best” is elevated and ‘the rest’ are meant to sit in silence. In this atmosphere, the commonly sung American folk song had all but vanished. Dorian Lynskey, author of โ€œ33 Revolutions Per Minute: A History of Protest Songs,โ€ theorized that American individualism in music also has its role in this musical shift. Older songs used the word “we.” “We shall overcome.” Or, “All we are saying is give peace a chance.” The spirit of “we” as found in community and cooperation is largely absent in modern pop music.

…until recently. Now the old protest songs are being taught to new voices. Now we’re reaching across aisles, across cultures and preferences, trying to anchor ourselves, our country, and each other.

A song heard at almost every singing protest, many of you are already familiar with Heidi Wilson’s “Hold On.” The words are simple, the tune adapting easily to harmony, and it has reverberated – from the U.S. to Cornwall to Wales and Ireland to Australia and beyond. A new generation of singers is carrying this song with them, and like a stone dropped into a pond, its message of quiet, almost prayerful endurance is rippling outward.

And when you learn from writer and composer Heidi Wilson the impetus behind the song she wrote in 2020, you’ll understand what a gift it truly is.

“Weeping may endure for a night, but joy comes in the morning.” Psalms 30:5b

Hold On

Hold on, hold on

My dear ones, here comes the dawn

– Heidi Wilson,
Plainfield, VT 2020
(Sheet music free at the link above. Please compensate and support the musician if you can.)

“Music mends minds” at the Kay Dolby Brain Health Center, San Francisco

Though sometimes when The Director pulls a song we’ve not done in a few years, we feel like we’re totally out to sea, never doubt the power of music to stay in our memories – somewhere. KQED’s recent report on the power of music to support people living with Alzheimer’s presents a powerful argument for staying involved with music for your whole life. Details about the program, including where to RSVP if you’re interested in showing up are here.

๐Ÿ˜–This orchestra is perhaps THE WORST… Which is great! ๐Ÿฅณ

Well, we’re told to make a “joyful noise,” but the Creator didn’t mention the emphasis being particularly on the noise part… A recent story by KPBS (a public media station based in San Diego, California (operated by San Diego State University in cooperation with NPR and PBS) shared footage of the worst orchestra you’ve probably never heard of. The Coronado Terrible Orchestra is demonstrably bad – and they’re really okay with that. Their director, Cassie O’Hanlon, wearing a black T-shirt bearing the words “Be So Kind To Yourself Right Now,” explained that the idea for the group came first from The Really Terrible Orchestra of Scotland, and another terrible group in the last town where she’d lived.

โ€œSo I was inspired by the same concept ultimately in Fort Wayne, Indiana, where I moved here from. There was a terrible orchestra. So when I moved out here, I kind of started noticing, at least south, thereโ€™s just not as big of a music community. So I just thought, why not try?โ€œ

We love to watch the Littles at Christmas during the pageant or processing through the sanctuary with their palm branches and hosannas. Little ones are celebrated for learning incompletely and performing badly all the time… but in our society, that’s a grace adults aren’t given. Can we make a space in our lives where the joy and connection – and not the perfection in music is what we’re about? While we don’t have to belong to a really terrible orchestra to make mistakes – we all do it every week – but as we learn, may we also keep patience and a sense of humor in the forefront of our hearts as we make our joyful noise together.